UEFA has been warned there could be ‘mutiny’ among its member clubs once a verdict is reached on Manchester City’s charges from the Premier League.
The focus on this issue has intensified following Everton’s recent deduction of 10 points for a breach of Financial Fair Play (FFP) rules. Speculation is now rife regarding how this decision might impact any forthcoming sanctions against City if the allegations against them are proven true.
The Premier League’s investigation into Manchester City spanned several years and involved accusations of financial misrepresentation to football authorities. However, the club vehemently denies any wrongdoing and will have the opportunity to defend its position at an independent tribunal.
It is worth noting that these charges come in the wake of UEFA’s own investigation into City’s breach of FFP rules, which resulted in a two-year ban from the Champions League. However, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) overturned this decision, stating that City’s only offense was a lack of cooperation with the UEFA investigation.
Despite the CAS verdict, which cleared City of major wrongdoing, doubts still linger in the court of public opinion. Liverpool is among the clubs that will be watching on with interest, considering it has been City’s biggest rival for silverware in recent times.
Pep Guardiola, Manchester City’s manager, expressed his frustration at not being given an opportunity to defend the club before public condemnation. As the club prepares its legal defense for the independent panel, the potential consequences for both Manchester City and the Premier League loom large. Dr. Gregory Ioannidis and Dr. Dan Plumley, writing in the International Sports Law Review (quotes carried by the Manchester Evening News), highlight the danger faced by UEFA regarding its self-regulation and predict serious unrest among member clubs.
“There are different dynamics present that control the decision-making of all stakeholders,” they wrote. “Whatever the result of the present dispute, it is almost certain that UEFA will face serious unrest from its member clubs to a point of mutiny.”
The charges against Manchester City are unprecedented in nature and are expected to take years to resolve due to their complexity. While it is possible that City could be found guilty of non-cooperation with another investigation, the burden falls on the Premier League to prove its most damning allegations. The Premier League must go beyond arguing that City failed to cooperate and instead demonstrate that the club provided inaccurate financial information or lied about it. The seriousness of these allegations raises the standard of proof required in this case.
Leave a Reply